Best Italian Restaurants in Siena
Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars
In the heart of Tuscany, Siena's culinary scene pulses with an authenticity that feels almost sacred. Here, tucked away in medieval stone buildings and intimate osterie, you'll discover Italian dining at its most genuine. The city's restaurants aren't trying to impress tourists with flashy presentations or trendy fusion concepts. Instead, they honor centuries-old traditions, serving handmade pasta, locally sourced ingredients, and wines from the surrounding Chianti hills. Each meal feels like a celebration of what Italian cuisine was meant to be: simple, seasonal, and prepared with passionate attention to detail.
This guide brings you inside ten exceptional establishments that have earned their stellar reputations one satisfied diner at a time. From hidden neighborhood gems frequented by locals to renowned osterie that have perfected their craft over generations, each restaurant featured here maintains an impressive 4.5-star rating or higher. You'll find everything from intimate family-run trattorias where nonna still oversees the kitchen to sophisticated dining rooms where traditional recipes meet refined presentation. These aren't just places to eat – they're authentic expressions of Sienese culture and hospitality.
Featured Restaurants
La Taverna di San Giuseppe
Tucked away on Via Giovanni Duprè, La Taverna di San Giuseppe captivates visitors with its authentic Italian bar atmosphere and consistently exceptional experience that has earned nearly 3,000 glowing reviews. Travelers rave about this Siena gem for its welcoming ambiance and quality offerings that perfectly capture the essence of Tuscan hospitality. Reserve ahead if possible, as this highly-rated local favorite tends to fill up quickly, especially during peak dining hours.
Osteria La Sosta di Violante - La corte di San Giorgio
Tucked away on Via Pantaneto, this beloved osteria captures the authentic spirit of Siena with its warm, welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that draws both locals and visitors. With nearly 3,000 glowing reviews and a stellar 4.7-star rating, travelers consistently praise the genuine hospitality and satisfying traditional fare. Book ahead during peak tourist season, as this popular spot fills up quickly with diners seeking an authentic Sienese dining experience away from the main tourist strips.
Osteria degli Svitati
Tucked away on a charming Siena side street, Osteria degli Svitati has earned a devoted following with nearly 2,000 glowing reviews for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that caters to every palate. The restaurant's impressive 4.7-star rating speaks to consistently excellent food and service that keeps both locals and travelers coming back. Book ahead during peak tourist season, as this beloved neighborhood gem fills up quickly with those in the know.
Osteria Il Carroccio
This beloved Siena gem on Casato di Sotto has earned an impressive 4.6-star rating from nearly 2,000 diners who rave about its authentic atmosphere and consistently excellent food across various cuisines. Located in the heart of the historic city center, Osteria Il Carroccio offers that perfect blend of local charm and quality that keeps both tourists and locals coming back. Book ahead during peak season, as this popular spot fills up quickly with savvy travelers who've discovered its winning combination of great food and genuine Italian hospitality.
Osteria Nonna Gina
This beloved osteria in Siena's historic center captures hearts with its authentic Italian atmosphere and consistently excellent food, earning praise from over 1,700 diners who rave about the warm, family-run feel. The impressive 4.6-star rating reflects not just great traditional dishes but also the kind of genuine hospitality that makes travelers feel like locals. Book ahead during peak tourist season, as this gem's reputation for quality at reasonable prices makes it a favorite among both visitors and Sienese alike.
Ristorante La Locanda dei Tintori Siena
Tucked away on charming Via dei Pittori, this beloved Sienese gem delivers an authentic Italian dining experience that has earned rave reviews from over a thousand visitors. The combination of warm hospitality, quality cuisine, and reasonable prices creates the perfect spot for travelers seeking genuine local flavor without breaking the bank. Book ahead during peak tourist season, as this highly-rated neighborhood favorite fills up quickly with both locals and savvy visitors.
Ristorante Campo Cedro
This beloved Siena gem on Via Pian D'Ovile has earned an exceptional reputation among locals and travelers alike, with nearly 650 glowing reviews praising its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant's impressive 4.9-star rating speaks to consistently excellent food and service that keeps diners coming back for more. Book ahead during peak tourist season, as this popular spot fills up quickly with savvy food lovers who've discovered one of Siena's best-kept culinary secrets.
Culinary Experiences in Siena
Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences